Tag Archive for review

The Devils Workshop by John Scherber

the devils workshop by John Scherber
TITLE:                        The Devil’s WorkshopAUTHOR:           John Scherber

RRP:                               Varies

 
 
 
The blurb for The Devil’s Workshop on Scherber’s site reads: An investment advisor falls 27 floors to his death in St. Paul. An auxiliary bishop is strangled in Houston. An art gallery owner dies in Santa Fe in the middle of the night. Their only link is an obscure painter living underground in Mexico, pulling the levers of a plan of revenge that goes back to the 1530s. Homicide detective Ken Abrams and mystery writer Rebecca Stuart unite to root out a plot so fiendish it could only have originated in The Devil’s Workshop. Beware what paintings you hang on your walls.

The Devil’s Workshop is a surprising book. For a long time I wasn’t sure I actually liked it but by the end I can honestly say I did – just not in a conventional manner.

I would like to start by saying I  liked the writing – I found the narrative reminiscent of Bogart style gangster films and almost expected the hero to be wearing a trench coat and fedora for most of the story (he didn’t).  There is something very solid about Scherber’s writing, although I’m not sure if that explains what I mean.  Perhaps confident is a better word – this is not a writer begging you to love his story, this is a writer who knows his story and is putting it out there for you to do with what you will. I liked that. A lot.

I liked the plot – rather arrogant yet subtly insecure writer meets mid-life crisis detective (sans fedora)and together they must save her assistant – the geeky and self effacing Jeremy – from the clutches of a murderous group out to kill the descendants of a member of the 16th century Mexican aristocracy. They do this by entering the homes of the victims via paintings by a painter, Cantu.

I loved the premise – the Mexican arsticocrat found himself father to two ‘deformed’ children. Deformed mostly in aesethetic terms, the children were banished underground with tutors and carers – and where they soon ‘created’ a new line. The new line developed several new evolutionary traits that were passed down through the generations forcing the line to remain in exile – among them the painter.  But times, as the great Dylan sang, they are a-changing….and the painter is not happy with being in exile and wants those above ground to pay.

So far, so good.

There were however two things I did struggle with.

The first was an editing issue and was really minor. There were a couple of places where there were shifts in tense, sometimes mid paragraph, or in point of view – that could easily be fixed.  Nothing major – and not enough to stop me reading, but sufficient to be noticeable and it’s not impossible I’m simply being pedantic because I am by day an editor.

The other issue was the characters. I’m afraid I just didn’t like them. I didn’t like Jeremy, the assistant, and I really wanted to. Nothing beats the underdog rising to the top and showing everyone else how it’s done – just look at how popular The Big Bang Theory is – but I just found him to be too wishy washy. I didn’t especially like Ken, the hero, who should have been swooping in and saving the day but was busy having a midlife crisis and worrying about getting his butt kicked by a girl to do that. Rebecca Stuart, the heroine, not only kicks his butt, she saves it several times and I should have liked her. I would have liked her had she been somewhat less obnoxious and superior. Most of the time I wanted to tell her to get over herself.  The one character I did like was Luisa, from the underground clan. I not only liked her, I found her very realistic – especially when she was angry.

That said, it’s not impossible to dislike huge chunks of a book and yet still like the whole and I have to say this turned out to be the case with The Devil’s Workshop.  Although some questions were left unanswered – how did the small people get through the canvases, what was the significance of Ken’s dreams, and did Luisa survive, and what possessed him to name a character Bloodbath – that doesn’t bother me at all. I don’t believe all loose ends need to be tied off in a story – in fact I quite like it when we don’t get all the answers. When did life ever give all the answers? It works very well in this story, to not have everything tied up neatly.

If you’re looking for something that will make you think a little this is a good choice and I would like to read some more of Mr Scherber’s work since his imagination is certainly impressive and engaging.

Reviewed for The Kindle Book Review

Crossed by Ally Condie

Crossed by Allie Condie

The second book in the Matched series,Crossed continues to follow Cassia and Ky as they resist the Society and try to think – and live for themselves.

Xander, Cassia’s official match, has helped Cassia to follow Ky who has been sent by the Officials to fight The Enemy at the frontier. Cassia’s family have also helped by suggesting Cassia is rebellious and should be in the work camps near the frontiers. After befriending another girl, Cassia makes a break and runs away, determined to find Ky and be with him.

Ky has also run and is equally determined to find Cassia and as he does so, his own story begins to unfold.

When the two finally find each other, more choices are presented and they begin to see choice is not always easy.

This second installment is told by both Ky and Cassia, in alternating chapters and points of view. The pick up from the first book is seamless and despite the regular switching from one character to another , there is no break in the narrative and the characters lose nothing from being seen through another’s eyes.

Xander, while not a prominent figure in this story, remains an important charcter, constantly in the back of the character’s minds as well as the background of the story.

Throughout Crossed, Condie calls the growing rebellion against Society The Rising. As a longtime Bruce Springsteen fan I made an immediate association with his song of the same name and  couldn’t help wondering if she was too.  So, after reading Crossed, I did visit Ally Condie’s website and was pleased to find that yes, she clearly was – and that I had indeed made the correct connection.

I’m looking forward to Book Three and the conclusion of this beautiful story that offers more depth and stimulation than most popular offerings on the YA market of late.

Matched by Ally Condie

Matched_by_Ally_Condie

I began reading Matched with no preconceived notions about what was coming or what the writing would be like. I’d never heard of Ally Condie nor read any of her books.  I did no research on her at all – I simply slid the book out of the envelope from Penguin and began reading. It says a lot about Condie’s talent that I was a third of the way into the book before I realized the story was being told in the first person present – something I normally avoid.

Matched is the story of Cassia, Xander and Ky – three 17 year olds who live in the future…some time. We never learn exactly how long in the future the story is set, except that is far enough away to be ‘after the warming’ and have air trains, but close enough that artifacts such as a compact engraved with 1940 are still around.

Society is now heavily controlled, not by guns and violence but by control itself. Choices have been narrowed to the bare minimum and everything possible is done for – not to mention delivered to – the individual.  Everything is decided by the Officials so that Society runs well.

All Society individuals carry three tablest – a red, a blue, and a green. The blue contains sufficient nutrients for an individual to survive several days without food and the green is calming. Nobody is sure about the red but many believe it is fatal as it can only be taken on the orders of an Official.

People do not cook – their food is delivered based on what each individual requires in terms of calories and nutrients. Each person specialises in one area of work and learns no other in any form. Those who plant grain, do not grow it; those who grow it do not cook it.

At 17 those who have chosen to be matched, rather than remain singles, attend a Matching Banquet – where they are presented with the best possible match for them based on personality and phsyical traits. The choice is made by the Society Officials.

Cassia’s match is unusual in itself when she is matched with a boy not only from her town, but one with whom she is friends: Xander.  Thrilled that she has been matched with someone she cares about, she returns home to view the data card, only to be presented with someone else’s face. This second ‘match’ is also a boy she knows – Ky.

A visit from an Official informs Cassia there has been a mistake, she must not worry, her match is in fact Xander and that everything has been fixed. When she is warned she must keep the mistake to herself, she asks if she may tell her grandfather who is about to ‘celebrate’ his 80th birthday. Permission is granted only because members of Society die on their 80th birthday – the one day they may choose the food they wish to eat.

At his final banquet, Cassia’s grandfather gives her something forbidden. Two handwritten poems which both entrance and terrify the young woman until sick with guilt she destroys them.

The loss of her grandfather, the turmoil of the matching error, and perhaps good old adolescent contrariness, all begin to play on Cassia’s mind and she begins to make friends with Ky. Before long, she has fallen in love.

Caught in a triangle, the guilt of posessing and destroying something forbidden and terrified of the outcome for her family, Cassia begins to question the control Society Officials have over people, and finds herself resisting the path matched out for her by those studying and controlling the data.

When Cassia receives the final test to place her as a Sorter she discovers she has sort Ky and on impulse makes a choice she hopes will give Ky choices Society no longer has. Unfortunately the decision results in Ky being sent away and Cassia learning there had been no mistake – she, Xander and Ky were part of a controlled experiment to see what would happen if individuals were allowed to react with emotional choice.  Cassia, her family and the surrounding neighbourhood are ordered to take the red tablet, setting the scene for Book Two in the series: Crossed.

Beautifully recounted by Cassia, Matched is one of the best books I have ever read and would certainly be, with the follow up Crossed, my pick for this year.

Flawless story telling, sympathetic characters, and a disconcerting sense that Society, as imagined by Condie, is closer than we would like, make Matched a compelling read.

 

Brother/Sister by Sean Olin

brother sister

TITLE:                 Brother/Sister

AUTHOR:            Sean Olin

RRP:                        $26.00

PUBLISHER:     Penguin

 

The story of Will and Asheley, a brother and sister who have been left to their own devices most of their lives. Abandoned by their father and brought up by an emotionally, and sometimes physically, absent, alcoholic mother, the pair have made it through high school mainly by sheer determination.

Will, although having left behind acne and bad clothes, is still socially awkward and given to outbursts of violence, while Asheley, quiet and solitary, is looking for more acceptance.

Told in alternating points of view and as if the pair are answering questions being asked in a police interrogation, Brother/Sister paints an increasingly disturbing picture of a dysfunctional family and teens who have stepped across the line from social angst to social danger.

Olin skilfully paints both characters in a way that it is impossible to not feel both sympathy and horror for them. He closes in on subjects like incest without any squeamishness or attempt to make it sound acceptable or inevitable; nor is there any glorification of any of the violence that unfolds.

Stark rather than graphic, it’s impossible to not feel something when reading this book. It does require a more mature reader – in emotion if not chronological age – and probably would appeal more to boys than girls. Be prepared for questions if the reader is younger and be very sure you are prepared to be as honest in your answers as Olin is in his writing.

I’m not sure you can call this an enjoyable read but it is definitely a very good read and a timely one given we live in a society and an age where violence is often glorified and the true horror of having performed an act of violence rarely expressed.

Olin also managed to surprise me with the ending – a rare occurrence indeed as I’m usually one of those annoying people who figures plots out (I spent the entire time watching Sixth Sense muttering “oh come on people, he’s dead, what is wrong with you all?”)

RATING: 9/10